A Cost-Saving Roof Over for a Florida School – But Was It Ready for Hurricane Season?

An example of Structura View's building enclosure consulting technology.
Topics for this article: Case Studies, Social Posts

When an aging roof needs attention, a roof over can be a cost-saving option. By installing a new system over the existing deck instead of tearing everything off, building owners save money, shorten the schedule, and keep disruption to a minimum. For a school working within a tight budget, those savings matter.

But in Florida, saving money is only half the equation. The roof also has to stand up to uplift pressure from hurricane-force winds, which means the new system must have proper adhesion to the existing roof.

Understanding the quality of that bond was the challenge facing the project team. The design called for an adhered modified bitumen system over polyisocyanurate insulation, installed on the school’s existing gypsum deck. Keeping the deck in place made the project cost-effective. It also raised a critical question: would the new system bond strongly enough to that existing deck to resist the uplift forces of a major storm?

Once the roof was complete, the bond would be hidden from view for good. And with hundreds of students, teachers, and staff depending on that roof every day, “probably” wasn’t good enough.

Bringing In an Independent Set of Eyes

The project team turned to Structura View to perform independent bonded adhesion pull testing. The goal was to get objective, third-party data on the bond strength between the insulation and the substrate, from a firm with no stake in the outcome other than getting it right.

Sixteen test locations were prepared by the roofing contractor using adhesive spaced at 6″ on center. Structura View then tested each location using two methods:

  • Locations 1–8: continuous load testing, pulling until failure or until testing was stopped
  • Locations 9–16: stepped load intervals, consistent with the ANSI/SPRI IA-1 standard

Using both methods gave the team a fuller picture of how the assembly performs under steady and incremental loading.

The Results

The numbers were decisive. Fifteen of the sixteen test locations reached loads between 1,500 and 1,800 pounds-force (lbf) without the bond failing. Testing was stopped once the results were well above the required minimum.

One location, test seven, separated at 1,130.9 lbf, where the adhesive released from the insulation facer. Even so, the overall results showed the assembly performing well beyond what was required. Values more than doubled the required minimum, and once that substantial safety margin was confirmed, there was no need to push further.

Savings Without the Risk

With verified data in hand, the project team didn’t have to rely on assumptions, manufacturer claims, or the installer’s word alone. The results confirmed that the new roof system had bonded strongly to the existing deck, with uplift resistance well beyond the design requirements.

Those results meant the school could keep the cost savings of a roof over without gambling on its performance. Construction moved forward, and the people responsible for keeping students safe and dry gained peace of mind heading into future storm seasons.

Why Independent Testing Matters

A roof over is often the most cost-effective path forward, but only if the new system truly bonds to what’s already there. Independent quality assurance testing provides objective confirmation that a roofing system is performing as intended, before the next phase of construction covers it up.

Verifying the bond during construction costs far less than discovering a problem after the first big storm.

Considering a roof over? Let’s make sure it’s built to hold.

Topics

Recent Articles

After the Flooding Rain: How to Review Your Roof’s Performance

After the Flooding Rain: How to Review Your Roof’s Performance

Massive, devastating flooding swept through much of Florida's east coast after days of relentless rain. Palm Bay, Malabar, Melbourne, Port St. Lucie and West Palm Beach were among the hardest-hit communities, with roads under water and people rescued from flooded cars...

Every Patch Bought Time. The Damage Kept Spreading Underneath.

Every Patch Bought Time. The Damage Kept Spreading Underneath.

A Florida facility was dealing with recurring leaks, ponding water and a patched TPO roof rated only "fair." Each leak meant another repair call and another patch. Meanwhile the big question went unanswered: is this a repair job, or a full replacement? For an owner or...

It Hadn’t Rained All Day. The Roof Was Still Leaking.

It Hadn’t Rained All Day. The Roof Was Still Leaking.

Quote it wrong, and everybody loses. This contractor wouldn't quote until they knew where the water was coming from. Five leaks in a medical building, no clear source, and some of them were dripping with no rain at all. The roofing contractor had to put a price on the...

Ready to work with
Structura View?

Structura View Logo Green and Blue
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.